Olisi’s NY

Reviews

• Amanda W.

  star star star star star_border 19 June 2026

  My husband and I came here at the recommendation of a friend. I love love love pizza. He likes pizza a normal amount, and he prefers his pizza to be NY Style- thin crust.
  
  We picked up an order for a large pizza, 10 wings, and a combo platter appetizer. My favorite part-you can order online! I love this! We placed the order online and it was ready about 30 minutes later. All of the food was pretty good, standard thin crust pizza, average pizzeria wings. The combo platter really made me happy though. You don't see an option like this at a lot of pizzerias. It came with jalapeño poppers, chicken fingers, and mozzarella sticks. A little something for every taste!
  
  We will definitely Be back to fulfill his NY style pizza cravings.

• Cassi S.

  star star star star star_border 18 June 2026

  Their pizza is good - not your traditional buffalo style, but thinner and crispy. The crust was my favorite part. The pizza itself was good, I ordered pepperoni and mushrooms, not too much or too little of either. The wings were decent but I would have preferred saucier and crispier. Garlic knots were very tasty and flavorful. Overall I would recommend and do plan on returning!

• James D.

  star star star star star 16 June 2026

  While in Buffalo I was craving some authentic NY pizza. I know Buffalo has its own style of pie, but a floppy slice of pep was on my mind. I did a quick search and found Olisis. This place is everything you'd expect a pie joint to be. Unique pies sitting at he counter waiting to be reheated to its glory. I'd highly recommend anyone come grab a slice. It was pretty busy at 2PM when I was dining in. Plus they have orange Fanta on tap.

• Michelle Z.

  star star star star star_border 6 June 2026

  I have been looking for NY style pizza for a very long time. I came upon two on yelp and this was one of them. So I wanted to give this place a try first. The store style is like any other pizza place.
  
  When I was looking at the displayed pizza, I realized that only the cheese and pepperoni pizza was the closest to the NY style pizza. So I got the pepperoni and of course I have to get the garlic knots. The garlic knots was good. The pepperoni pizza was good as well but the crust itself was not crispy enough. The pizza wasn't as big as the ones you buy in NYC but it didn't really matter for me. If the crust is crispy I would've probably gave it a 5 star. Will continue to go back and also try the other place.

• Daniel W.

  star star star star_border star_border 29 May 2026

  Stopped here for lunch after driving by many times. The inside was very nice. Very clean feel. They had tons of slice options up at the counter from standard pepperoni to specialty slices. This is a NYC style pizza not Buffalo style. I tried a slice of cheese and pepperoni and a slice of the steak which had banana peppers and a mix of cheddar and mozzarella on it. Both pieces of pizza were very bland. Absolutely no flavor on the steak pizza, I could only taste the mild banana peppers. The big pepperoni I am never a fan of because it tastes cheap compared to the nice cooked cupped up pepperoni that is normal to Buffalo. I usually go down the street to a much better option. Some of the best pizza around is at Molinara's it's like a mile down the road. Go there instead and you will not be disappointed with your slice.  I am not really interested in trying Olisi's again despite its convenient location to my work and clean atmosphere. I didn't finish either slice.
  I did think the price for two slices and a drink was reasonable.